Showing posts with label power. Show all posts
Showing posts with label power. Show all posts

Wednesday, 27 June 2007

Human impacts on or in the environment?

Another thought which illustrates for me the inadequacy of a division between the nature and unnatural, or between nature and society. This one was triggered by a passage from Bill McKibben's book The End of Nature, which is quoted in a Rough Guide to The Earth as suggesting that:
we could let human activity alter the climate so that a hotter-than-before day is essentially a human artifact. But if we take steps to stop altering the climate, a normal cool day is also an artificial event which we have decided to create (Ince, 2007: 272).

Thus, by actively choosing to mitigate global climate change by reducing carbon dioxide emissions we are still creating a human-altered/influenced/managed environment. Through our very presence, self-awareness and power to effect environmental change, whatever we as a species choose to do represents a choice of type of impact in our environment, rather than a choice of level of impact on the environment. This is especially the case given the level of global awareness which has emerged in the past half-century.

This is illustrated on a smaller scale by the management of nature reserves and national parks, which ranges from hands-on management to hands-off 'un-management', and with varying degrees of intervention in between. All of these types of management represent active choices to effect a certain outcome which we have determined is best. And the same is true on the global scale in the case of climate change. Trying to view nature or the environment as a separate domain in which we can choose our level of impact is clearly unrealistic - because of our presence, self-awareness and power to effect environmental change we are always choosing our type of impact. Some form of environmental impact will always result from our actions as a species, since we are a part of our environmental system, not a separate unnatural or social domain.

The question: whether breaking down the division between nature and society in our thinking would lead to a better understanding of the effect that human activity has within our environment?

Tuesday, 13 March 2007

Who swindles who?

My initial reaction to the first 15 minutes of The Great Global Warming Swindle was surprise - at the seeming strength of the programme's argument that the consensus view on climate change, and at the credentials of some of the interviewees. The programme, which aired on Channel 4 (UK) on 8 March (and More4 12 March) was created by documentary-maker Martin Durkin, and presented what seemed a coherent argument against the anthropogenic CO2-based greenhouse warming theory, based on the influence of sunspots and solar activity.

As the programme progressed, accusing the west of using this climate change argument to prevent the global south developing (there obviously being only one route to 'development'), my skepticism increased and as soon as it ended, I went to the internet to poke around - if there's discrediting to be done it's happening in real time on the internet somewhere. And sure enough, the 'environmental journalists' criticised by the programme had responded. Robin McKie's article in the Observer illuminated the backgrounds of some of the those interviewed and reminded readers of the apology issued by Channel 4 following the airing of a previous Martin Durkin documentary.

According to the Independent, Professor Carl Wunsch of MIT is considering making a formal complaint after being misrepresented by the programme-makers, claiming in a statement posted on his website that the programme is "an out-and-out propaganda piece, in which there is not even a gesture toward balance or explanation of why many of the extended inferences drawn in the film are not widely accepted by the scientific community."

So it becomes clear that this is another example of a debate covering both the scientific community and the media in which the truth is not clear cut, and where the media is used to manipulate people's opinions. And it is here the there is some value in a programme like The Great Global Warming Swindle.

As a student of geography with an active interest in environmental issues, I tend to side with those termed environmentalists when confronted with a black and white choice. The Great Global Warming Swindle reminds us that we should remember the intimate link between knowledge and power, and not to be blind to this connection even amongst those working on issues close to our own hearts. Environmental awareness and 'protection' is now a massive industry, and as such now shares the same power-laden discourse status as many other issues where our skepticism might be more healthy.